Sak Vid Pa Kanpe: Food Rioting Begins in Haiti

By Bryan Schaaf on Friday, April 4, 2008.
see more topics in:

I expected to hear of food riots in Haiti.  Life has never been easy for Haitians but escalating food costs have made just getting by more and more difficult.  If you and I went a day without eating and did not know if the next day let alone the next week would bring more of the same, I would not be writing this and you would not be reading this - we would be out in the streets protesting!

 

What took me by suprise about the rioting was the form it took.  Approximately 5,000 protestors stormed and looted both a police station and a UN base in the southern town of Les Cayes.  Police stood by as the proestors stole rice from trucks.  I didnt expect this in Les Cayes, a fairly mellow town in the south that is prosperous compared to most parts of the country.  That this happened there is an indication of the desperation people feel.

 

I did however expect it in Gonaives.  Ever since Haiti has existed, both social movements to revolutions have started in Gonaives.  Hundreds demonstrated while UN workers were evacuated to a police base.  Protests remained peaceful. According to the UN police spokesman, there were no injuries except for one demonstrator who was shot in the foot. 

 

 

People talk of Haiti as if it was stuck in the past.  To the contrary, Haiti is in the future - about 100 years in the future.  The problems that Haiti struggles with including overpopulation and envrionmental degradation are the same issues many other countries will struggle with if the world does not change.  As an old Peace Corps colleague put it, Haiti is the canary in the mine that alerts us to the fact that something is very wrong with the world in which we live.  We are all going to struggle with the same problems, but Haiti struggles first.   

 

 

According to the Globe and Mail,  80 per cent of Haitians live on less than $2 a day. Rice, the Haitain staple, is up 50% from the year before. Beans, condensed milk and fruit are reported as going up at a similar rate with spaghetti having doubled.  When mangos double, we know we're in trouble.

 

 

UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon, a strong advocate for Haiti, stated that food insecurity threatened to unravel the progress of the past year in terms of stability, economic growth, and governance.  When a peson is not eating, food is priority number one.  Everything else can and will wait. 

 

The article notes that there is graffiti all around Port au Prince declaring “Down with the expensive life!"  So much depends on ensuring that Haiti is able to feed itself.  Living in dignity depends on being able to meet the needs of one's family. 

 

 

In a previous blog, we laid out some ideas for short and long term solutions.   We would like to hear yours as well.

 

Bryan 

 

 

FAO to Discuss Food Shortages in Haiti

The following link notes that food shortages may be here to stay. Also notes a UN Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO) Conference on bifouels and food shortages in Haiti.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20080410/wl_nm/brazil_un_food_dc

Editortal in NYT: Rich Nations Must Do More (4/10/2008)

Most Americans take food for granted. Even the poorest fifth of households in the United States spend only 16 percent of their budget on food. In many other countries, it is less of a given. Nigerian families spend 73 percent of their budgets to eat, Vietnamese 65 percent, Indonesians half.

They are in trouble. Last year, the food import bill of developing countries rose by 25 percent as food prices rose to levels not seen in a generation. Corn doubled in price over the last two years. Wheat reached its highest price in 28 years. The increases are already sparking unrest from Haiti to Egypt. Many countries have imposed price controls on food or taxes on agricultural exports.
Prices are unlikely to drop soon. The United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization says world cereal stocks this year will be the lowest since 1982.

The United States and other developed countries need to step up to the plate. The rise in food prices is partly because of uncontrollable forces — including rising energy costs and the growth of the middle class in China and India. This has increased demand for animal protein, which requires large amounts of grain.

But the rich world is exacerbating these effects by supporting the production of biofuels. The International Monetary Fund estimates that corn ethanol production in the United States accounted for at least half the rise in world corn demand in each of the past three years. This elevated corn prices. Feed prices rose. So did prices of other crops — mainly soybeans — as farmers switched their fields to corn, according to the Agriculture Department.

Washington provides a subsidy of 51 cents a gallon to ethanol blenders and slaps a tariff of 54 cents a gallon on imports. In the European Union, most countries exempt biofuels from some gas taxes and slap an average tariff equal to more than 70 cents a gallon of imported ethanol. There are several reasons to put an end to these interventions. At best, corn ethanol delivers only a small reduction in greenhouse gases compared with gasoline. And it could make things far worse if it leads to more farming in forests and grasslands. Rising food prices provide an urgent argument to nix ethanol’s supports.

Over the long term, agricultural productivity must increase in the developing world. Mr. Zoellick suggested rich countries could help finance a “green revolution” to increase farm productivity and raise crop yields in Africa. But the rise in food prices calls for developed nations to provide more immediate assistance. Last month, the World Food Program said rising grain costs blew a hole of more than $500 million in its budget for helping millions of victims of hunger around the world.

Industrial nations are not generous, unfortunately. Overseas aid by rich countries fell 8.4 percent last year from 2006. Developed nations would have to increase their aid budgets by 35 percent over the next three years just to meet the commitments they made in 2005.

They must not let this target slip. Continued growth of the middle class in China and India, the push for renewable fuels and anticipated damage to agricultural production caused by global warming mean that food prices are likely to stay high. Millions of people, mainly in developing countries, could need aid to avoid malnutrition. Rich countries’ energy policies helped create the problem. Now those countries should help solve it.

Last week, the president of the World Bank, Robert Zoellick, warned that 33 nations are at risk of social unrest because of the rising prices of food. “For countries where food comprises from half to three-quarters of consumption, there is no margin for survival,” he said.

Preval's Speech

The article below contains excerpts of Preval's speech to the public after the protests. It was undoubtedly the most important speech of his presidency - a shame he did not deliver it before everything boiled over though. People are desparate and need to be informed and engaged. Preval noted the need for improved national production and raised the possibility of subsidizing national agricultural crops, fertilizer, etc. This would help the agricultural sector get back on its feet and compete against imports.

ttp://www.alertnet.org/thenews/newsdesk/N09327614.htm

Reply to Melinda

Melinda, zap me an email at bryan@haitiinnovation.org. Let's discuss.

Food Riots in Port au Prince (3/7/2008)

Rioting took place in Port au Prince today. You can read more at:

http://www.miamiherald.com/news/americas/haiti/story/486223.html

Hunger protests in Haiti

Hello Bryan,
I am a fan of the site and your blog in particular. I live in Jacmel, Haiti and am working with a group of organizations to build the Haitian National Coalition for the Environment. I wanted to connect with you, and now that I have read your blog I thought I would share mine for today, a similar topic: http://konpay.org/en/node/219

I will link to yours there. Thanks for everything you are doing to share information about Haiti.

Kenbe fem, Melinda Miles

Self Reliance

The Haitian agricultural sector could be expanded to meet the needs of its own people. As a net importer in a globalized world, this makes Haiti very vulnerable to price fluctuations. Haiti needs to be able to produce its staples - the rice, the beans, and the corn - that people rely on for survival. Unless we can halt environmental degradation, self reliance will remain out of reach...

food riots in Haiti

The issue underlying this is that the rice is imported - as is the majority of Haiti's food.... there is an embargo on the chickens and eggs from the DR...Across the border - the DR is a net exporter of food. But Haiti has lived for years on remittances, on charity, on buying rather than producing, so now it has nothing that it grows excpt the fine fresh vegtables and the great fish from its waters and the coconuts and mangos.

Post new comment

Please solve the math problem above and type in the result. e.g. for 1+1, type 2.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.